I’ve been hearing lots of good things about the Jinhao 159, from folks talking on Youtube and the FP Geeks forum, to Brian Goulet’s video about this inexpensive Chinese pen. Goulet Pens offers them in Black, Orange and Yellow, for $12.50. I had previously purchased a Jinhao X450 on ebay in June of last year, and it was ok. So I bought this 159 for around $5 including shipping on ebay. It took a long time to arrive – nearly 6 weeks – and I was beginning to lose hope. I really enjoy using this pen, although not for long periods, which I will discuss later. And in doing the research for this blog post I realized I didn’t do an actual review of the Jinhao X450 so I will compare the two pens in this post.
Here is the 159. Of course one is put in mind of a Montblanc 159 and it is definitely an homage to that iconic pen. It’s not an exact knockoff though as it has Jinhao on the silver band on the cap, and no white star on the top of the cap. I have never held a Montblanc so I have no idea if it’s close in the feel or not but it certainly looks like one.
The pen takes international cartridges (short and long) and comes with a converter. I always prefer the performance I get out of a pen using a converter and this pen is no exception.
The pen weighs 50 grams and believe me you can feel it. It’s an extremely big pen and I would not recommend it for long writing sessions. My hand got tired after writing for about five minutes. But I love the look of it and the weight of it, to be honest. When posted the pen feels perfectly balanced. The nib is smooth and the flow is super wet. I put J. Herbin’s Bleu Pervenche in it and it’s a gorgeous combination.
Here’s a closeup of the nib. It says Jinhao but also 18K. Brian Goulet explains in his video that the nibs are all stamped 18K but only some of them are gold plated (the two tone ones). The nibs on the 159 are stainless steel.
Here’s a writing sample. A great writer but I found after just one page my thumbnail was digging into my index finger. It just wasn’t super comfortable. This made me think of my X450 and I wondered how the writing experience compared.
In June 2014 I bought the Jinhao X450 on ebay. I can’t remember how much I paid but currently these pens are available on ebay for just over $5. And I think it’s good value for the money, for both the X450 and the 159.
The pen is a rich royal blue with gold coloured accents. And the nib is a beautiful two-tone. I don’t see 18K anywhere so it may not be gold plated. It’s lovely to look at and great to write with. This pen is much smaller in girth than the 159 and notice the grooves on the indented section. Those grooves really enhance the writing experience for me.
When I first got this pen I put a J. Herbin Eclat Sapphir cartridge in it and I wasn’t pleased with the results at all. Perhaps the cartridge was old or something but the pen skipped and went dry almost immediately. For this post I put a standard converter with Waterman’s Serenity Blue in it and the writing experience has been the exact opposite: great flow with smooth writing. A good writer indeed.
I wanted to show you the caps and bands because the pens don’t even look like they come from the same manufacturer. The X450’s band has a written Jinhao while the 159 is printed. The clips are not the same size, nor do they have the same design. The 159 sports a chariot driven by two men brandishing a whip while the X450 has three simple dots. The X450 has a snap cap and the 159 is a screw top. Interesting pens that’s for sure.
And finally a size comparison. From left: Pilot Metropolitan, Jinhao X450, Cadence, Jinhao 159, Monteverde Prima in Purple Swirl, Lamy Al-Star and Visconti Rembrandt. The 159 is the biggest and heaviest pen I own. Thank goodness it’s fun to write with.
Please let me know your thoughts on the Jinhao 159 or the X450, or even just the brand in particular. At these price points it’s fun to experiment. 🙂
I’m also a lover of the fountain pen and have just 4 in my collection (several are sitting in my Amazon cart).While I’ll admit that they are not brand name pens, I expect them to work, but they don’t. The worked for the first few months and then, trouble and frustration. They write when I refill them and by the next morning – nothing, no ink flows to the nib. What would you suggest is a good method to get the ink flowing so that I can use my fountain pens? Thanks in advance for your help.
If you wish you may contact me via email cherylwright55@gmail.com .
LikeLike
Cheryl I haven’t forgotten about you, sorry it’s taken me awhile to respond. When you say they are not “brand name”, can you share what brand they are? When you leave them overnight, are they capped? And have you cleaned them regularly? I find regular cleaning does wonders. If you are keeping them capped when not in use and cleaning them regularly then I suggest you make the leap into brand name pens from a reputable seller such as Goulet Pens or Wonder Pens. That way if you have problems with the pen they can assist you. Hope that helps. Let me know how you get on. 🙂
LikeLike
Please, no apologies necessary. You replied quite speedily.
One is a X450 Kurve Fountain Pen by Bulow®, one has Senator on the clip, one has no name but diamonds (not real of course) on the top of and around the upper rim of the cover and one is just a school grade fountain pen.
Yes I always keep them covered and when I clean them, they write for 2/3 days and stop.
I do so long for a fountain pen that writes and writes and writes. So, I am going to buy one of the Jinhao pens.
Thanks so much.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m glad you are going to pick up a Jinhao, they are generally reliable. I forgot to mention a lot has to do with the ink you are using as well. I had a lot of problems with my Monteverde Prima in Green Swirl (an $80 pen) which was surprising because I had no problems with two others of the exact same brand. I had been using cartridges in it and when I switched to a converter with bottled ink (J. Herbin Vert Pre) the difference was amazing. No more hard stops and skipping. That pen really prefers a converter and perhaps that is the case with your pens. Just a thought. You can pick up Parker Quink ink at just about any office supply store and it is a good ink to try with those stubborn pens of yours. Good luck and keep us posted!
LikeLike
I will definitely try that Parker Quink Ink and will let you how things go. Thanks again for your help.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Happy to assist. 🙂
LikeLike
Pingback: Journal Writing Wednesday: 12 pages | inlovewithjournals
Pingback: Details of the Thank You for 500 Subscribers Giveaway | inlovewithjournals
What Brand and model pen does the Jinhao X-450 look like?
LikeLike
In my limited experience I’m not sure which model the X450 looks like. If you figure it out let us know!
LikeLike
I think the Montbanc Meisterstuck 146
LikeLiked by 1 person
You are obviously more educated about Montblanc products than I am! I looked up the 146 and you are right, they do look similar. Thanks!
LikeLike
Pingback: A New Colour for my Jinhao 159s | inlovewithjournals